Islam, A Very Short Introduction
Malise Ruthven, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1997 (2000)
Chapter 1: Islam, Muslims, and Islamism
Islam means
‘self-surrender’ and is etymologically related to salaam, the word for peace
(the universal Muslim greeting is“as salaam `alaikum” –– Peace Be Upon You).
Islam can be seen as a religious faith, a political ideology, and a mark of
group identity (in that sense ‘Muslim’ is like ‘Jewish’).
Islam as Identity
In one sense, you are a Muslim if you are born to a
Muslim father. The Muslims of Bosnia, for example, are not noted for their
religious identification. In theory, one can be an atheist Muslim, while
one cannot be a Christian atheist.
Islam
as Political Ideology
There
are a couple of problems with using “fundamentalist” to apply to Muslims who
want to establish an Islamic state:
·
All
Muslims given this label have adopted some modernistic/allegorical
interpretations of the Quran
·
all Muslims, not just the
“fundamentalists” see the Quran as the eternal unmediated word of God
Throughout its
history, Islam rectitude has been shown by orthopraxy (practice) more
than orthodoxy (doctrine).
Muslims of the
militant tendency want, in the terms of Sayyid Abul `Ala Maududi
(1903-79), to replace the sovereignty of the people through parliamentary
legislation with the ‘sovereignty of God’ as revealed through the Shari`a
–– obedience to the revealed law of Islam. BUT
·
no
Islamic society has ever been governed exclusively by Islamic law
·
the
ideology advanced by Maududi and his ilk are really hybrids, mixing Islamic
ideas with 20th century ones.
Islam as Faith
The classical
authorities distinguished between islam (professed by the Muslim)
and iman (faith of a true believer (mumin), part of the umma
–– worldwide community of believers).
Who counts as a true
Muslim?
The Puritanical Kharijis
(Seceders) deny grave sinners the right to be called Muslims
The Murji`a
(opponents of the Seceders) allowed that anyone who proclaimed the shahada,
the public declaration of faith enshrined in “there is no god but God; Muhammad
is the Messenger of God”.
Abu Hanifa, father of one
of the four Sunni legal schools, stated that “those who face in the direction
of Makka at prayer are true believers and no act of theirs can remove them from
the faith.”
Now the majority
of Muslims believe that iman and islam correspond to the inner
(or esoteric) and outward (or exoteric) manifestations of the
faith.
Chapter 2: The
Quran and the Prophet
The Quran (in
its original meaning, the Recitation) is the primary text of Islam,
understood as the unmediated word of God, whereas the Hadiths (‘traditions’)
are other sayings attributed to Muhammad, but of a lesser stature.
The Quran
Occupies for
believing Muslims the role Christ does for Christians.
Must not be
handled unless one is in a state of ritual purity.
Readings must be
preceded by the phrase “I take refuge with God from Satan, the accursed one”
and followed by “God Almighty has spoken truly!”
Certain verses
are said to have curative powers, for example, the first sura
(chapter) for scorpion stings.
The Quran is
generally accepted by non-Muslim scholars to be a collection of the divine
utterances made by Muhammad in the course of his prophetic ministry from around
610 to his death in 632 CE. Because the original Arabic script lacked the marks
that now distinguish consonants clearly from each other, there are competing
interpretations, seven of which are seen as equally valid. It consists of 114 suras
(chapters) arranged approximately in order of length, longest to shortest,
except that the first sura (the Fatiha or opening) is only seven verses,
and is repeated during the 5 prayers Muslims perform every day.
The fundamental
message of the Fatiha (the ‘Mother of the Book’) is repeated and elaborated
throughout, in stories from the Judeo-Christian tradition, featuring Adam,
Noah, Abraham, Joseph, Moses and Jesus, along with Arabian prophets and sages
like Hud, Salih, and Luqman.
God (or
occasionally the Angel Gabriel or other angels), not Muhammad, is speaking through
the Quran, as evinced by the fact that many utterances are prefixed by the
imperative “Say:” addressed to Muhammad. There is no coherent narrative
structure running through the book, although it includes self-contained
narratives.
Differences from
Christianity:
along with Abraham taking Ishmael rather than Isaac, these include the view
that Adam repents after the sin and becomes God’s deputy (khalifa), the
first prophet in a line ending with Muhammad. Also Jesus, while a prophet born
of a virgin, is not the son of God or God. Without a terrestrial incarnation of
God, there is no Church on earth, and all one needs to do to be saved is fallow
God’s commands. Instead of Jesus, Muslims have the Quran, the words of which
are divine in themselves.
Sira (Biography)
Although
Muhammad is mentioned by name a few times in the Quran, it includes no details
of his life. His first biography was written by Ibn Ishaq, who died in
767 CE, 135 years after the prophet’s death. There are others, including
material by Tabari (d. 923) which includes the Satanic Verses
episode (where one of the recitations revealed contained positive references to
three Makkan goddesses, al-Lat, al-Uzza, and Manat) not
found in other sources.
Muhammad was
born around 570 CE in Makka, a member of the Quraish tribe, whose job it
was to be guardians of the sanctuary that included the Ka`ba, the square
temple towards which all Muslims orient themselves in prayer, and which was
supposedly built by Abraham (or Ibrahim) to mark the spot where the almost-sacrifice
of Ishmael (or Isma`il) took place. Muhammad was orphaned at 6 and
brought up by his grandfather then his maternal uncle Abu Talib. As a
young man he entered the service of a wealthy widow, Khadija, who later
became his first wife, and bore him seven children (some of whom died). At the
age of about 40 Muhammad began taking regular retreats to a cave near Mt. Hira,
where, after a period of meditation, he received his first revelation
(described in the 53rd sura of the Quran). At first Muhammad
reported his visions to few people: among those to whom he did, who accepted
them, were Khadija (sometimes called the first Muslim) and Abu Talib’s son (and
hero to the Shi`a) `Ali.
When Muhammad
did go public, he attracted followers and enemies, the latter in particular
(according to Ibn Ishaq) when he disparaged the pagan deities (western scholars
suggest he himself practiced some pagan rituals early on, in keeping with the
Satanic Verses episode). The leader of the Quraishi opposition was Abu Lahab.
Originally Muhammad was protected by his uncle he died the same year as
Khadija, depriving Muhammad of two crucial supporters. However, his fame led
him to be recruited by visitors from Yahtrib (later named al Madina,
City of the Prophet), an oasis about 275 miles NE of Makka, to act as mediator
among tribal clans, including the Aws and the Khazraj and the
Jews, who owned the best date palm farms, but had no military, and were allied
to both rival clans. Muhammad went there in 622 (which marks the beginning of
the Muslim calendar) enacted a document regulating the political relationship
among these groups decreeing that they form a single community (umma),
within which Jews (and even, at this early stage, pagans) would have religious
freedom, provided they did not side with the community’s enemies. (Muhammad’s
relationship with the Jews deteriorated later, as his political power grew and
as the Quran developed as a scriptural alternative to the Torah. Eventually,
Muhammad and followers take Makka by force in 630 CE. He enters the Ka`ba
and destroys all but two (Jesus and Mary) of the icons within, including those
of the three pagan goddesses of the Satanic Verses. In that year, two, most of
the tribes in the Arabian peninsula submit to the Muslim Umma, now the most
powerful force there. The remaining pagans are allowed 4 months to make up
their minds to submit or be killed with impunity. The system of aligning the
lunar months with the solar year is abolished, severing the connection between
religious rituals and the seasons. Now the pilgrimage (Hajj) and the
Feast of Sacrifice (`Umra) –– formerly separate pagan festivals in
spring and autumn –– are compounded, and will regress through the seasons,
forming a complete cycle approximately every 33 years.
Muhammad returns
to Madina, falls ill, and dies in the arms of his favorite (and final of at
least 9, possibly 13) wife, `Aisha.
Hadith
‘Traditions’
Hadiths are
discrete anecdotes about Muhammad’s sayings and doings, originally passed down
orally. Different versions of the same stories were recorded, sources cited,
making a kind of patchwork. Because much depended on the reliability of the
sources, the hadith transcribers investigated the character of their sources,
and hadiths were graded by reliability into ‘sound’ (sahih), ‘good’ (hasan)
or ‘weak’ (da`if). Six collections achieved canonical status, two of
which, the sahihain (‘two sound ones’) of al-Bukhari (d. 870) and
Muslim ibn al-Hajjaj (d. 875) considered second only to the Quran in
importance.
Given the long oral
period before transcription, the reliability of hadiths has been called into
question. Contemporary western scholars suggest that the reported chains of
transmitters (isnads) had a tendency to “grow backwards” –– that is, be
created after the fact to make it seem like the stories had roots in antiquity.
The Elaboration
of Muhammad’s Image
While Christians
are enjoined to imitate Christ in his gospel of love, Muslims should go much
further in imitating Muhammad, right down to sitting down to put on trousers,
putting one’s right shoe on first, and avoiding foods he disliked, including
garlic, mangoes and melons. While he should not be represented in sculpture or
art (lest the artist be seen to appropriate God’s creative power) his actions
are described in great detail. Some of these include legendary status,
including the miraculous splitting of the moon and feeding of 1,000 people from
a single sheep. Muhammad is also the ‘seal’ of the prophets –– the last one. No
mystic thereafter can claim to have direct revelation without great challenge.
Chapter 3:
Divine Unicity
Tawhid
The word does
not occur in the Quran, but its concept –– unicity of God –– is evinced
throughout, especially in the credal formula there is no god but God. It
is a direct challenge to Arabian paganism, Zoroastrian dualism, and the
Christian doctrine of God incarnated in Jesus.
The First
Sectarian Divisions
Ironically,
terrestrial unity amongst Muslims lasted barely longer than the life of
Muhammad. After his death a dispute arose about succession, with `Ali (his
son-in-law as well as his uncle’s son) passed over three times. When he was
finally appointed, his leadership is contested, and he is eventually killed by
one of a group of his former followers who left (the khawarij or seceders),
this event marking the beginning of Shi`ism. `Ali’s two son’s took
different paths, both of which have been emulated by the Shi`a since: Hasan,
the eldest, compromised with those who resisted `Ali’s leadership, while the
younger Hussein revolts and is killed at Karbala, now in Iraq,
and the site of one of the holiest of Shi`ite shrines.
What began as a
power struggle developed into an ideological dispute as the issue of leadership
is perceived as necessary to salvation. In 749, a Shi`i-inspired movement leads
to the formation of a new dynasty, moving the capital from Syria to Iraq.
However, the new ruler (caliph) is still not a descendent of `Ali. The
Shi`a leader, the Imam Ja`far, follows Hasan’s strategy and coexists
with the new ruler, but the Imams remain a threat to the Caliphs, and (so Shi`a
legend has it) are murdered each in their turn until the Twelfth Imam, Muhammad
al Muntazar (The Awaited One) disappears altogether. He will return at the
end of time as the Messiah (al-Mahdi) to bring peace to a strife-torn
world. Thenceforth Shi`a communities formed at the fringes of the Muslim world,
waiting for the return, oscillating between the strategies of Hasan and
Hussein.
Other Branches
of Shi`ism
The followers of
the Twelfth Imam, who now number about 80 million (including Iranians) are
known as Imamis or Ithna`asharis (‘Twelvers’). A minority sect
claims allegiance to Isma’il, eldest son of Ja`far, and are thus
known as Isma`ilis or ‘Seveners’. Their decendents include two
prosperous modern groups from India –– the Musta`lian Bohras, and the Nizari
Isma`ilis, who believe that their current Imam, known by his Persian title
of Aga Khan (and one of the richest people in the world) is the 49th
Imam in direct line of descent from `Ali.
Other Shi`a
sects include:
·
The
Zaidis of Yemen recognize Zaid ibn `Ali (grandson of Hussein) as
the fifth Imam over his brother.
·
The
Druzes of Lebanon
·
The
`Alawis of Syria
·
The
Babis of Iran (which gave birth to the separate religion of Bahaism)
All Shi`a
recognize the death of Hussein in ‘the massacre of Karbala’ as the
defining myth, re-enacted on its anniversary with processions of bloody
flagellants who inflict wounds on themselves as self-punishment for betraying
the Prophet’s grandson. The Shi`a Imams are the nearest equivalent in Islam to
the Christian priesthood, a class missing from Sunni Islam.
Tawhid in Early
Islamic Thought
There are
related philosophical disputes in early Islamic thought about free will,
the justice of God, the status of the Quran as created or uncreated
and anthropomorphism, all of which must be interpreted in the light of
Tawhid –– the essential oneness of God.
In the Quran God
curses Abu Lahab (Muhammad’s chief rival amongst the Quraishi) and predicts for
him a roasting in hell. But this appears to take away from Abu Lahab’s freedom,
and predestine him, which seems unjust (if he is not free in his actions, why
roast him for them?) Debating this reveals two different views of the status of
the Quran:
The created Quran:
on this view (attributed to the Shi`a, but certainly to a group of Sunni
theologians called the Mu`tazila), there is a distinction between the personal
attributes of God and God’s actions. The latter, which includes his
speech, which includes the Quran, are created by God. On this view,
then, Abu Lahab’s fate is just a prediction, not a promise –– Abu
Lahab still can embrace God and save himself. However, traditionalists (the
Sunni) do not distinguish God’s actions from God’s essence, and espouse the
view of the uncreated Quran –– the Quran as existing forever because it
is an aspect of God. However, the Mu`tazila see this as shirk (the
opposite of tawhid –– ‘associationism’ or ‘idolatry’) because it suggests that
there is something besides God, that is, the object of God’s eternally existing
actions (as all actions must have objects). They also see insist that some
passages of the Quran that appear to anthropomorphize God, by referring
to his eyes or his foot, must not be taken literally, because it
associates earthly features with the transcendent otherness that is God.
A former
Mu`tazili, Abu`l Hasan al-Ash`ari (d. 935) laid out a compromise: the
Quran was uncreated and God has foreknowledge of human action but
humans have free will because of the doctrine of acquisition: God creates
the power for people to ‘acquire’ actions created by him at the instant of
action. For Ash`aris, ultimately God is inaccessible to human reason, and he
can both have legs and not have legs and we must accept this bila kaif,
“without asking how.”
The Sunni
Consensus
After the
failure of the caliphate (the union of political and spiritual power),
religious authority was in the hands of the `ulama, a class of religious
scholars whose authority was based solely on their knowledge of scripture. The
Sunni `ulama are like protestant preachers in that
·
there’s
no clear ‘pecking order’ among them
·
virtually
anyone can become one, so among Sunnis
any qualified
[Islamic] lawyer can decide whether something is against Islamic law, so there
can be as many versions of “orthopraxy” as there are jurists [60]
·
without
leadership, interpretation returns to the text, so there is a tendency towards
conservatism
Theosophical
Speculations
Speculation
about God, influenced by the Greek Philosophers (particularly the Neoplatonists)
was encouraged under the Isma`ili Imams, who valued reason below only God. This
led to a kind of elitism about interpreting the Quran: the literal meanings
were known to the many, but the inner (esoteric) meanings were known only to
the few. For example, heaven and hell were not really actual places, but
states of being. This differential understanding was shared by the great
Spanish Philosopher Averroëës (Ibn Rushd, 1126-98].
Sufism
The mystically
inclined Sufi (named after the coarse shirts of wool (souf) worn by some
early examples, also rejected literal readings and close observance of the
Quran. One of the earliest Sufis was Rabi`a al-Adawiya, a poet from
Basra, who refused to marry, and ran through the streets with a torch in one
hand and a jug of water in the other, saying
I am going to
light fire in Paradise and pour water onto Hell, so that both veils may be
taken away from those who journey towards God [that] they may look towards
their Sustainer without any object of hope or motive of fear.
This symbolizes
a key notion of Sufism, that love of God should be pure and disinterested
(note: NOT the same as Uninterested). Despite occasional persecution (e.g., the
crucifixion of the famous mystic al-Hallaj (857-922)), perhaps brought
on by apparently blatant shock tactics (making the forbidden wine instead the
symbol of piety, and flirting with homoeroticism) ‘drunken’ or ecstatic Sufism
has existed alongside legalistic Islam through the ages. Perhaps the greatest
Sufi philosopher was Ibn `Arabi (1165-1240) who was accused of pantheism
because of his statement that “nothing exists except Allah.”
Chapter 4: The Shari`a
and its Consequences
There is no
Incarnated God to match Jesus in Islam, and God has not revealed himself or his
nature, but only his law –– the Shari`a. This means much more than law
in the narrow legal sense, including all rules for rituals, customs and
manners. It is there both for the good of society and for helping humans
achieve salvation.
The juristic
literature through which the Shari`a is elaborated is known as fiqh
(‘knowledge’/’understanding’ or more narrowly, ‘jurisprudence’). The four roots
of fiqh, are listed below in order of importance.
The Four Roots
of Islamic Law
1. Quran
Only about 10% of the Quran can be read as requirements of law (including
family law (marriage, divorce, inheritance) and rules about witnesses and
commercial regulations), and there are apparent contradictions.
2. Sunna
This is the vast body of hadiths, many of them of questionable origin,
and containing many contrary claims.
3. Ijma`
(‘consensus’) The jurist Muhammad b. al-Hasan al-Shaibani (749-805)
declared that “whatever the Muslims see as good is good with God, and whatever
the Muslims see as bad is bad with God.” This allows that circumcision (male
and female) is required, even though it has no sanction other than Arab custom.
4. Qiyas
(analogical reasoning) For example, are alcoholic drinks forbidden? While some
jurists say only the fermented products of the date-palm and vine are
forbidden, others argue that all alcoholic drinks share the same effect which
is the reason for date-palm wine to be forbidden (see “Wine or Whisky” on p.
80).
Ijtihad: The Struggle
for Truth
Ijtihad shares the same
root as jihad, and means the struggle to fathom the law as revealed by
God and Muhammad. The Shari`a is divine, co-eternal with God. Fiqh is a human
creation. The faqih –– one who practices fiqh –– must, through ijtihad
reach conclusions about the Shari`a. The schools of Sunni legal thought are
named after their founders:
·
Muhammad
ibn Idris al-Shafi`i
[767-820) Rural Egypt, Palestine, Jordan, coastlands of Yemen, Indonesia
·
Abu
Hanifa (699-767)
–– the HANIFI school, more liberal than the one below dominant in the Balkans,
Transcaucasia, Afghanistan, Pakistan, India, Central Asian republics, China
·
Malik
ibn Anas al-Asbahi
(713-795) –– the MALIKI school dominant in Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia, Libya
·
Ahman
Ibn Hanbal
(780-855) –– a traditionist who eschewed ijma` wherever possible.
The four Sunni
schools all agreed that the ‘gates of ijtihad’ closed after the third Muslim
century, but for the Shi`ites, they remain open, allowing greater flexibility.
Every senior Shi`i ulama known by the title of hujjat al-islam (‘proof
of Islam) or Ayatullah (sign of God’) is a mujtahid –– individual
interpreter of the law, and every believing Shi`i is supposed to look to one
for guidance.
The Shari`a: An
all-encompassing Ideal
The Classical
lawbooks divide all human behavior into five categories:
1. Required,
obligatory (wajib or fard) ‘for the neglect of which one should
be punished, and for the doing of which one should be rewarded.’ Include both
individual duties (fard`ain) and collective (fard kifaya) like
participation in the jihad.
2. Proscribed or
prohibited (mahzur, haram) acts ‘for the performance of which
there is punishment, and for the avoidance of which there is reward.’ Include
the hudud offenses mentioned in the Quran.
3. Recommended (mandub,
masnn, mustahhab, sunna) acts ‘for the doing of which
there is reward, but for the neglect of which there is no punishment.’ Include
charity and fasts.
4. Discouraged
or odious (makruh) acts ‘for the doing of which there is no punishment,
but for avoiding there is reward.’ Could include divorce.
5. Permitted but
morally indifferent (jaiz, mubah) acts ‘for the performance or
avoidance of which there is neither punishment nor reward.’
The Shari`a and
Muslim Societies
One problem with
the Shari`a’s extremely individualistic approach is that it does not recognize
the public sphere, does not accord the state a role distinct from religious or
private affairs, and this can encourage nepotism and cronyism.
Chapter 5: Women
and Family
Historically the
patriarchal family and the extended networks of kinship connected with it have
proved to be among the most durable social structures in Muslim societies…… The
role of religion in sustaining these structures is not entirely clear. Islamic
law privileges the family over other institutions: the laws of inheritance,
favoring males over females, are written in the Quran along with other
discriminatory provisions, such as the testamentary inferiority of females in
certain proceedings. [But] slavery and concubinage…… also the subject of
detailed legal provisions and though widely permitted under the Shari`a, both
have disappeared (in theory if not always in practice) from Muslim societies.
Patriarchy is
neither only Islamic (many non-muslim societies are, of course, patriarchal)
nor necessary to Islam (there are Muslim communities in West Africa and
south-east Asia where matrilineal systems of ownership and inheritance rule).
Women and the
Shari`a
Traditionalists
argue that Muhammad greatly improved the lot of women pre-Islam (the jahiliya,
“time of ignorance”) –– granting women some inheritance, limiting the
number of wives allowed to four, and the Quran is directed to both sexes.
BUT: women are
allowed only half their brothers’ inheritance, and in court a woman’s testimony
counts half a man’s. And to argue that this should change means to assault the
idea that the text of the Quran is literal and always true.
Traditionalists
can point out that in practice, the rules of the Quran are fairly
liberal. While it sets out very nasty punishments for unfaithful wives, it also
sets out standards of evidence for proving this that are almost
impossible to meet. Furthermore, if a deserted or widowed woman becomes
pregnant, she is protected against accusations that she has been unfaithful by
the legal fiction (hila) of the ‘sleeping fetus’ –– according to
which a pregnancy can be allowed to last up to even 7 years, so the child is
seen as that of the missing/dead husband. Another hila is the ‘public bath’
whereby it is allowed that an unmarried woman who becomes pregnant can claim
this happened by sitting in a pool of semen at a public bath. (What goes ON at
these baths?)
HOWEVER, the
practice of inheritance is usually worse for women than the theory.
Marriage and
Divorce
According to
most legal authorities, a woman’s wali (guardian –– usually the father)
enters into a marriage on her behalf, and thus a virgin can be forced to marry
her father’s choice of husband. Only the Shi`ia view the woman as ‘a full legal
entity, coequal with her male counterpart.’ But for all Muslims the husband as
the right to divorce by talaq (unilateral declaration) –– declaring ‘I
divorce you’ three times (with a gap of three menstrual cycles between the
second and third). Muslim men can marry “people of the book” but Muslim women
cannot.
A man’s right to
sex is divinely instituted –– a wife must accede to her husband’s sexual
appetites. In Shi`ism there is even the practice of “Temporary Marriage,” which
can last as little as one hour, which allows any man to have sex if he can get
a woman (or her guardian) to agree to the contract.
Islam and
Sexuality
Muslims are no
prudes: there are no monks or nuns, and the Prophet’s sexual prowess is lauded.
(He is said to have had possibly 13 wives, and to have had sex with all nine he
was concurrently married to in one night.) According to the Tunisian Scholar Abdelwahab
Bouhdiba, an orgasm is just a foretaste of what Paradise will be like for
all eternity. That said, homosexuality is considered (by all but Sufis) to be a
major sin.
Women in Social
and Religious Life
There is strict
separation between Muslim men and women in the public domain. A woman’s social
circle must be confined to her female friends and her mahrams –– male
relatives that she cannot marry. In all but the most liberal mosques, women
must worship separate from the men (usually either in seclusion, or at the
back, separated by a curtain).
Islam and
Feminism
Muslim feminists
argue that it is not Islam that is sexist, but the men who interpret it.
However, feminism is typically seen as ‘Western’ and rejected as cultural
imperialism. Seeking a way round this, writers like the Moroccan Fatima
Mernissi and the Egyptian-born Leila Ahmed have promoted ‘indigenous
feminism,’ arguing that the ethical principles of Islam and its commitment to
social justice irrespective of sex run counter to the restrictions women are
currently under. The important role of early female Muslims, including
Muhammad’s first wife Khadija, the first Muslim, and his last, `Aisha,
who is the source of many hadiths (so much so that in one tradition the Prophet
is supposed to have told Muslims that they ‘received half their religion from a
woman’).
Muslim women are
speaking out: even in conservative Sunni Saudi Arabia, women demonstrated
publicly to be allowed to drive.
Chapter 6: The
Two Jihads
Jihad (‘stuggle’) is a
collective obligation for Muslims, distinct from the individual duties
such as prayer. In Islam’s period of rapid expansion, it was akin to the Roman
principle of just war, making chivalric rules for battle sparing women,
children, the sick and the weak, and protecting the Peoples of the Book.
However, the classical doctrine does divide the world into two camps –– the
sphere of Islam (dar al-islam) and the sphere of War (dar al-harb),
wherein enemies should convert (polytheists) or submit (Peoples of the Book).
In theory Islam was supposed to sweep the world, but this, like the second
coming of Christ, has been indefinitely postponed.
The Greater
Jihad
According to a
well-known hadith, Muhammad distinguishes between the war on polytheists (the lesser
jihad) and the ‘greater’ jihad against evil, which can be interpreted as the
struggle every Muslim is in throughout his or her life. This kind of peaceful
conversion has actually been more responsible for the spread of Islam (through
trading routes, for example) than the military campaigns, although Islam has
had to adapt to local customs (as the traveller Muhammad ibn `Abdulla ibn
Battuta (1304-77) discovered when he came to the Maldives and was asked to
be a judge: despite his urgings, the women refused to wear any more clothing
than a loincloth, yet considered themselves good Muslims).
The New Jahiliya
A radical member of the Muslim
Brotherhood, Sayyid Qutb,
executed in 1966 for an alleged plot to overthrow the Egyptian government,
would prove to be the Sunni Muslim world’s most influential Islamist theorist.
Some of Qutb’s key ideas, however, are directly
attributable to the Indain scholar and journalist Abul ‘Ala Maududi, whose works
became available in Aarabic translation during the
1950s. One of the Maududi’s doctrines, in particular,
would have a major impact on Islamic political movements. It was the idea that
the struggle for Islam was not for the restoration of an ideal past, but for a
principle vital to the here and now: the vice-regency of man under God’s
sovereignty. The jihad was therefore not just a defensive war for the
protection of Islamic territory or dar al-islam. It might be wages against governments which
prevent the preaching of true Islam, for the condition of jahiliya
(the of ignorance before the coming of Islam) was to
be found currently, in the here and now.
Qutb advocated the creation of a
new élite among Muslim youth who would fight the new jahiliya as the Prophet has fought the old one. Like
the Prophet and his Companions, this élite must
choose when to withdraw form the jahiliya and
when to seek contact with it. His ideas set the agenda for Islamic radicals
throughout the Sunni Muslim world. Groups influenced by them included
·
Shukri Mustafa, a former Muslim Brotherhood activist and
leader of a group known as Takfir wa
Hijra (‘excommunication and emigration’) who followed
the early Kharijis in designating grave sinners (in
this case the government) as kafirs
(infidels);
·
Khalid Islambuli and ‘Abd al-Salaam Farraj, executed
for the murder of President Anwar Sadat
in October 1981; and the
·
Hizb al-Tahrir (Liberation
Party) founded in 1952 by Shaikh al-Din al-Nabahani (1910-1977), a graduate of al-Azhar
whose writings lay down detailed precriptions for a
restored caliphate.
The leading
Shi ‘i exponent of Islam as a revolutionary ideology
was ‘Ali Shari‘ati (d. 1977), a historian and
sociologist who had been partly educated in Paris. Though without formal
religious training Shari‘ati reached large numbers of
youth from the traditional classes through his popular lectures at the Husainiya Irshad, an informal
academy he established in Tehran. Shar‘iati’s
teachings contain a rich mix of ideas in which theosophical speculations of
mystics like Ibn ‘Arabi and
Mulla Sadra were blended
with the insights of Marx, Sartre, Camus and Fanon
(whose friend Shari‘ati was and whose books he
translated into Persian). The result was an eclectic synthesis of Islamic and
leftist ideas. God was virtually identified with the People, justifying
revolutionary action in the name of Islam. An outspoken critic of those members
of the clergy who acquiesced in the Shah’s tyranny, Shari‘ati
drew a distinction between the official Shi‘ism of
the Safavid dynasty (1501-1722) which made Shi‘ism the state religion in Iran and the ‘revolutionary’commitment of such archetypical Shi‘i figures as the Imams ‘Ali and Hussein and Abu Dharr al-Ghifari (a Companion of
the Prophet often credited with socialist principles). Shari‘ati’s
ideas, disseminated by means of photocopies and audio tapes, provided a vital
link between the student vanguard and the more conservative forces which
brought down the Sha’s regime. The latter were
mobilised by Sayyid Ruhallah
Khomeini who had come into prominence as the leading critic of Sha Mohammed Reza Pahlavi’s
‘White Revolution’ during the early 1960s. The Sha’s
agricultural and social reforms threatened the interest of the religious
establishments, not least because the estates from which many of the ‘ulama drew their incomes were expropriated or divided
up. Exiled to Najaf in Iraq, Khomeini developed his
theory of government - the Vilayet-e faqih (jurisconsult’s
trusteeship) - which broke with tradition by insisting that government be
entrusted directly to the religious establishment.
Appendix: The
Five Pillars of Islam
1. Shahada:
declaration of faith according the formula There is no god but God. Muhammad
is the Messenger of God. [Shi`i add: `Ali is the the Friend of God]
2. Salat:
worship/prayer. Ritual prostration in the direction of the Ka`ba in Makka,
which, for Sunnis, must take 5 times daily (dawn, noon, mid-afternoon, sunset
and evening) in a state of ritual purity. Congregational prayer takes place at
noon on Fridays. Women and men worship separately, women behind the men or in a
screened-off section.
3. Zakat:
alms-giving/compulsory charity. Tax, payable once a year by all adult Muslims,
assessed at 2.5% of capital assets over and above a minimum known as the nisab.
(For example, the nisab for stock is 5 camels, 30 cows or 40 sheep or goats.)
The recipients should be poor and needy.
4. Sawm:
the fast during the daylight hours during the holy month of Ramadan, the 9th
month of the lunar calendar, which applies to eating, drinking, sex.
5. Hajj:
pilgrimage to Makka –– required (at least) once in a lifetime, must take place
during the last ten days of the twelfth lunar month (Dhu`l al-Hijja) reaching
its climax with the Feast of Sacrifice (`Id al-Adha). When there, the
pilgrims perform rituals including the Tawaf, the circumambulation of the
Ka`ba; the Sa`I (seven-fold running between the hillocks of Safa and
Marwa, now covered in an air-conditioned gallery); the Standing on the Plain of
`Arafat, a few miles from Makka; the Onrush through the narrow defile of
Muzdalifa; the ‘Stoning’ of three pillars representing the devil; and
the sacrifice of an animal at Mina.